Entertainment Television

TV review: Syfy's uneven 'Treasure Island'

When I was a kid I watched the Disney "Treasure Island" every time it was on TV—Ahoy, ye mateys! I'd scream all over the house—so I was more than excited to see Syfy's "darker," updated version of the Robert Louis Stevenson classic.

It's colorful, ambitious and looks fabulous, but I advise you to DVR the four-hour affair (6 p.m. May 5, Syfy; 2.5 stars) and watch it over a couple of nights or you may lose interest. You'll likely lose interest any way; there is a reason Syfy is airing the entire mini-series in one Saturday night.

You also might dislike the updated ending, which isn't all that dark. I can't really tell you about it lest I spoil, but I will say it feels—like the scarlet macaw playing Long John Silver's should-be-green parrot—wrong. It's too PC for a schooner full of scoundrels.

Eddie Izzard, however, is the right man to play Silver, the pirate with the tattooed face who must saw off his own cannon-shot leg just minutes into the film. Izzard channels his tricky grifter character from "The Riches" to convey Silver's slippery, mixed up morality. One minute he wants to find old Captain Flint's (Donald Sutherland) treasure at any cost, the next he's mentoring young adventurer Jim Hawkins (Toby Regbo, also good), who has set sail with Flint's X map and a group of seemingly trustworthy adults to find Flint's gold.

But "Treasure Island," which also stars Elijah Wood, Philip Glenister and Rupert Penry-Jones bringing the swashbuckling fun, is all over the map, literally, when it comes to pacing. When it really sails, it cuts through the waves swiftly. But it loses wind so many times the thrills come only sporadically.

And the scarlet macaw? He doesn't say anything, not even "Ahoy, ye mateys!"

Copyright © 2015, RedEye
Related Content
  • Guide to May 2012 TV premieres, finales, specials

    Guide to May 2012 TV premieres, finales, specials

    May can be a difficult month for the serious couch potato, what with regular season finales happening at the same time new series are launching. So to help you out, here's a guide to the season and series finales, plus season, series, original movie and specials premieres happening in May. I'll...

  • Genealogy gold mine: Millions of wills now online

    Genealogy gold mine: Millions of wills now online

    Thousands of amateur genealogists who fantasize about being left a fortune by a distant relative can now get a reality check. Starting Wednesday, upward of 100 million wills written over the last three centuries will be posted to, the popular genealogical search engine.