Television
Entertainment Television

Review: An impossibly good new 'Doctor Who'

“Doctor Who” head writer and executive producer Stephen Moffat doesn’t lose one ounce of the Who-ness of his show by filming, for the first time in the show’s 48-year history, in the U.S.

Used wisely and not too much in the two-part season premiere, the Utah desert looks magnificent in “The Impossible Astronaut” (8 p.m. Saturday, BBC America; *** 1/2 out of 4 stars) and even better in next week’s “Day of the Moon.”

Moffat also has outdone himself with another insanely intricate story and his sinister new baddies, The Silence. This two-parter is jaw-droppingly good, but it is a bit confusing. I’ll write more about my issues with the plot in post-episode recaps, but for now, as the mysterious River Song would say: Spoilers!

Instead let’s concentrate on how wonderfully well Matt Smith, Karen Gillan and Arthur Darvill have grown into their roles as the time-traveling Doctor and his companions, Amy Pond and her mister., Rory Williams.

Just one year after debuting as the Eleventh Doctor, Smith is disarmingly charming as the freewheeling Time Lord, injecting The Doctor with a youthful zeal that’s as wild as his marvelously unruly hair. Smith always has delivered Moffat’s zingers with gusto, but he also gives him newfound gravity.

More than any time last year, this Doctor feels like an old soul bottled up in a rubbery young man’s body, with the solemnity of a man who has been there, done that for 900-odd years (depending, of course, on when you meet him).

Smith’s physicality, however, might be the most remarkable—and enjoyable—part of his performance. He can rouse laughter with a simple sweep of his hand at President Nixon just as effortlessly as he can conjure your concern by dejectedly cradling his head in that same hand.

Smith has settled into a rocking groove with his co-stars as well. Unlike at times last season, Gillan’s Amy doesn’t get lost behind the flashier Doctor or his, well, whatever she is to him, River Song (Alex Kingston, cheeky as ever).

Darvill, however, is the revelation. His is the least showy performance of all, but he can break my heart one second and make me laugh the next. Rory loves Amy and respects The Doctor, but he's torn about their adventures and their relationship. He fears he'll lose Amy to one of The Doctor's foes—or to The Doctor himself. With his subtle, nuanced acting, Darvill shows Rory's pain and misgivings as well as his surprise at the courage he ultimately musters.

Rory might seem like the third wheel in the TARDIS time machine, but he's become its beating heart. Jealous, proud, self-confident or crushed—but almost always confused and clumsy—Rory has become my favorite character.

Copyright © 2015, RedEye
Related Content
  • Matt Smith stays cool as 'Doctor Who'

    Matt Smith stays cool as 'Doctor Who'

    Matt Smith sounded just a little worse for wear last week during a phone chat between interviews for his series, “Doctor Who.”

  • New clues about Season 6 of 'Doctor Who'

    New clues about Season 6 of 'Doctor Who'

    UPDATED APRIL 5: BBC America offered more details Tuesday about Season 6 premiere of "Doctor Who," called "The Impossible Astronaut" (8 p.m. April 23). Check out the excerpt from today's release: "Lead writer and executive producer Steven Moffat on the new season: 'Oh, there's a big story being...

  • Mark Sheppard on 'Doctor Who' Season 6: Huge!

    Mark Sheppard on 'Doctor Who' Season 6: Huge!

    Mark Sheppard does appear in the two-part premiere of “Doctor Who,” called “The Impossible Astronaut,” premiering at 8 p.m. April 23 on BBC America.

  • 50 Cent at Parliament and Wyclef Jean at The Underground

    50 Cent at Parliament and Wyclef Jean at The Underground

    Shots in The Dark at Parliament Nightclub with 50 Cent and The Underground Nightclub with Wyclef Jean and Joey Fatone July 31st

  • Lolla day 1: Best and worst, plus superlatives

    Lolla day 1: Best and worst, plus superlatives

    One day down! Here’s the best and worst we saw at Lolla on Friday, plus a few superlatives from day 1. Best: Anyone who knows me knows I was bound to pick Paul McCartney as my favorite act of the day. The Beatle came out and gave it his all with more than two hours of hits, tributes and jokes about...

  • Lolla day 1: Let's just rename it Paul-apalooza

    Lolla day 1: Let's just rename it Paul-apalooza

    What can you really say about Sir Paul McCartney, the former Beatle, pop music pioneer, worldwide cultural icon, and all-around great guy, that hasn't already been said? I mean, seriously. With the Beatles changing music for the better, becoming a pop culture institution and being "more popular...

Comments
Loading
73°