Jessica Galliart: Remember those giant cookie pies with icing you could buy at the mall in middle school? Thanks for the nostalgia, Taco Bell.

Brian Moore: Tasteless icing, but the cookie is surprisingly tasty. Not chocolatey enough, however.

Jessica Cantarelli: You¿re likely to find better tasting cookies at a shady election day bake sale. Far too sweet with an unruly crumble to them.

Leonor Vivanco: Whoa, tastes pretty rich. There¿s got to be thousands of calories packed into this inch-thick cookie that has a overpowering layer of white frosting in the middle. But not enough chocolate chips.

Elite Truong: Crumbly, sad, instant sugar headache.