Taylor Swift, 'Cloud Atlas' and assumption junction

On semi-rare occasions, you absolutely know when something’s going to be good. You judge a book by its cover because you’ve practically already read it. A new Fiona Apple album, good. 3 Doors Down’s greatest hits, bad.

That said, it’s far too easy to let broad assessments determine what entertainment we pursue and decide how much we liked it before watching/listening/reading. This week Taylor Swift, that smiley little pixie who is like, so oh-my-god grateful, y’all about this award and totally did not expect it, released a new album. It would be easy to broadly dismiss as the singing diaries of a teenage girl who doesn’t realize that she’s in her early 20s. Or, at best, the sort of catchy, disposable pop that Hayden Panettiere’s character has already grown sick of writing and performing on “Nashville.”

In fact, Swift’s well-reviewed “Red” deserves the reviews that say it’s not terrible. It’s considerably better than terrible, something I imagine many people would be more willing to consider and perhaps admit were the album not by Taylor Swift, who already seems like she’s been around forever despite not having been born when “The Little Mermaid” came out. Contrary to belief that may have been fostered by some less-than-stellar awards show performances, Swift can sing just fine, and the hooks on “Red” cannot be denied. Will it force you to admit the way the music conjures images of putting the top down (if you had a convertible) and letting your hair fly in the wind? Probably, despite the lyrics possessing a far less carefree spirit. And even if not all of Swift’s words soar with wisdom, 1. She’s 22 2. They're honest and relatable and 3. Unlike Katy Perry's lyrics, they don’t make you gag.

By the way, that’s a mild reference to “Full House,” a show that began two years before Swift was born.

On the flip side, this week also brings “Cloud Atlas,” a movie that might seem guaranteed to be worth your time. It stars Oscar winners in Tom Hanks, Halle Berry and Jim Broadbent, and it’s co-directed by Chicago natives Andy and Lana Wachowski (“The Matrix”). It should go without saying, however, that ambition and name recognition doesn’t grant a movie a free pass—“Rock of Ages” should forever stand as proof that huge stars don’t mean a damn with horrible material. The fast-paced “Cloud Atlas” whizzes by pretty quickly for a three-hour epic that makes broad statements about human behavior, but it’s also embarrassing on a writing, acting and thematic level. Anyone who goes in already ready to be wowed may digest the concept of jumping across space and time and casting actors in several different parts as a brilliant experiment; subjectively, I say everything it tries is distracting in the worst way.

Most people, critics included, go into a movie or an album with a somewhat biased opinion. If critics says they anticipate “The Master” with the same excitement as “That’s My Boy,” they're lying. But everyone, whether they write about this stuff or not, should be willing to admit when something is good or isn’t, regardless of if they “want” to like it. Loved the “Twilight” books but shudder at the movies? That’s OK, it doesn’t change how you feel about the book. Heard the Animal Collective record is wonderful but you don't actually hear any songs on there? That's fine; being in the minority doesn't mean you don't get it, you just might have to work harder to defend your perspective.

The thing about opinions is that everyone has one, but in a savvy pop culture world in which many prefer not to go out on a limb and no one wants to be wrong, a discussion of artistic quality isn’t much worth having when minds have been made up in advance.

Watch Matt on “You & Me This Morning,” Friday at 6:55 a.m. on WCIU, the U



Want more? Discuss this article and others on RedEye's Facebook page.


Copyright © 2015, RedEye
Related Content
  • Your binge posting on Instagram makes me want to projectile vomit them back at you

    Your binge posting on Instagram makes me want to projectile vomit them back at you

    You don’t get out much. That we know for sure.

  • Byrne Interchange work: Get ready for traffic heartburn

    Byrne Interchange work: Get ready for traffic heartburn

    The heavy lifting will begin this month on the overhaul of the Byrne Interchange near downtown Chicago, leading to anticipated expressway traffic tie-ups mostly over four weekends stretching into the fall, officials will announce Monday.

  • The best performances of Lolla 2015

    The best performances of Lolla 2015

    We saw a lot of great shows this weekend, but these were the best of the best. It’s gotta be Paul McCartney for me. The man is a legend and seriously an amazing performer who knows how to give the people what they want. Lolla wasn’t the first time I’ve seen Paul, and I really hope it won’t be my...

  • 3 dead, 37 wounded in weekend shootings

    3 dead, 37 wounded in weekend shootings

    Shootings across Chicago left three dead and 37 wounded over the weekend, including a 5-year-old girl and a 7-year-old boy who were injured in separate shootings about five minutes apart Sunday evening.

  • Lolla day 3: Best and worst, plus superlatives

    Lolla day 3: Best and worst, plus superlatives

    Somehow, Lolla’s all over already. This is what we loved and didn’t enjoy quite as much from day 3. Best: I gotta give it to Florence and the Machine. Seems like an obvious choice, but she was just so fun and engaged with the crowd (and the storms). Even her songs I wasn’t familiar with were exciting...

  • Red carpet report: 'The End of the Tour'

    Red carpet report: 'The End of the Tour'

    This past January I was lucky enough to be on the red carpet before the Sundance premiere of “The End of the Tour,” which opens Friday in Chicago and stars Jason Segel as David Foster Wallace and Jesse Eisenberg as David Lipsky, the journalist interviewing Wallace as they travel during the last...