Entertainment Movies

Entertainment Entertainment Movies

'The Gatekeepers' review: Important and incomplete

**1/2 (out of four)

Before the Oscar-nominated documentary “The Gatekeepers,” members of Israel’s secret service known as the Shin Bet had never given interviews. So why were they willing to participate in this film? Why is it now OK to give an inside look into former missions and the feelings of the former heads of the operation?

Director Dror Moreh’s film does not answer these questions, nor does it do a particularly good job of providing context for the never-ending conflict between Israel and Palestine. Moreh relies primarily on the stories of, and his own interviews with, six former heads of the Shin Bet. This alternately provides fascinating accounts of ethical complexity, such as a case in which a rare attempt to consider collateral damage resulted in nearly all the targets surviving, and thinly sketched observations that require a lot more information about who these guys are, how they were chosen and what it was like to be in the organization.

“The Gatekeepers” poses difficult questions about the luxury of a moral high ground against an enemy that delights in the creation of suffering, but it does not feel nearly as nuanced or well-researched as “Zero Dark Thirty.” It’s impossible not to respond to accounts of the Shin Bet trying to deter the orders of extremist rabbis or stories of inaccurate intelligence that leads to the deaths of innocents.

Yet the film is lacking enough in information that I couldn’t help but look at one elderly former head of the Shin Bet and think, “People may have been scared of you then, but the only frightening thing about you now is the hair leaping out of your nose.” It doesn't derail the movie or anything, but producers really should have demanded those weeds be cut before shooting.

Watch Matt on “You & Me This Morning,” Friday at 6:55 a.m. on WCIU, the U



Want more? Discuss this article and others on RedEye's Facebook page.


Copyright © 2015, RedEye
Related Content
  • Bold predictions for Lolla 2015

    Bold predictions for Lolla 2015

    The Lolla schedule is sort of like the NCAA tournament: there are millions of possible combinations, and it’s anyone’s guess what the winning picks will be. With that in mind, we make some bold predictions about how this year’s fest (returning to Grant Park Fri.-Sun.) will turn out. Breakout artist...

  • 2010 killing of Chicago cop detailed at trial; man claims self-defense

    2010 killing of Chicago cop detailed at trial; man claims self-defense

    The man on trial in the killing of Chicago police Officer Thor Soderberg hated police and surprised the officer as he changed out of his uniform at shift end and placed his duty belt down, a Cook County prosecutor alleged Monday.

  • Aldermen to hold hearing on untested rape kits

    Aldermen to hold hearing on untested rape kits

    Chicago aldermen on Monday called on police officials to provide information on how quickly rape kits are being tested by the state crime lab, part of a largely symbolic effort to determine whether a large backlog is hampering work to apprehend rapists.

  • Alderman's 'Chi-raq' criticism falls flat

    Alderman's 'Chi-raq' criticism falls flat

    A South Side alderman's effort to tweak filmmaker Spike Lee for using "Chi-raq" as the title for a movie about Chicago violence fell flat Monday with his colleagues.

  • ComEd to hold energy fairs to help low-income customers

    ComEd to hold energy fairs to help low-income customers

    Commonwealth Edison will hold energy fairs at satellite locations across the region Monday in order to get money to thousands of people struggling to pay their electricity bills in northern Illinois.

  • PAWS Chicago "Muttshots!"

    PAWS Chicago "Muttshots!"

    These adorable pups are on the loose looking for a place to call home. They have a warrant out for their arrest. Their crime? Being irresistibly cute and cuddly. If you're interested in adopting any of these dogs, please visit www.pawschicago.org for more information.