Entertainment Entertainment Movies

'One Direction: This is Us' review: 1D in 3-D is 2-D

**1/2 (out of four)

At the screening for the 3-D concert documentary “One Direction: This Is Us,” many young women in the audience screamed at the first sight of the boy band—and it wasn’t even the movie. It was a commercial for the lads’ anti-bullying “Live Nice” partnership with Office Depot. This is outrageous for two reasons: One is the idea that bullies would stand down to the “live nice” motto. And two is that this group has reached post-Bieber levels of worldwide and local infiltration to the point that they make N’Sync and Backstreet Boys fandom look downright tame.

Still, “This Is Us” has an advantage that the Katy Perry and Justin Bieber docs didn’t: Its subjects are amusing, and the fun is contagious. As captured by director Morgan Spurlock (“Super Size Me,” several docs worse than that), Harry, Zayn, Niall, Liam and Louis, put together by Simon Cowell after each auditioned for “The X Factor,” come off as appealing goofballs who take an arrogance-free, fun-loving approach to their careers. Even when the movie avoids many relevant questions, it works as a travel comedy featuring dudes who are immature but not entitled, silly but not tiresome.

That extends from the entertaining live performances, during which 1D doesn’t do choreographed dances but sprinkles in intentionally amateur moves for the hell of it, to the backstage antics. They drive golf carts and, at one point, Niall undergoes extensive makeup and hair treatment to disguise himself as a security guard who hates One Direction.

While it’s sobering to hear the guys’ parents understandably long for more time and communication with their sons, who have been on the road since about 16, the film predictably contains zilch that can be considered controversial. (Harry admits that the rigorous schedule isn’t always fun, but even the most protective publicist has to allow that.) With this quintet spending all day every day together, is there ever any conflict? What do they fight about? Considering their songs deliberately exist as a certain romantic fantasy, how do they handle the female attention, and what are their relationships like with young women?

Spurlock doesn’t capture the answer, nor does he provide tangible perspective as the band members generalize about the many groups who come and go and the notion that, at some undetermined point in the future, they will no longer be famous. Coupled with the notion, as one member notes, that these may be the best days of their lives, that’s a tough thing for anyone to wrap their head around, much less a 19-year-old millionaire with the planet wrapped around his finger.

Watch Matt on “You & Me This Morning,” Friday at 6:55 a.m. on WCIU, the U



Want more? Discuss this article and others on RedEye's Facebook page.


Copyright © 2015, RedEye
Related Content
  • 'Welcome to Me' is highly gawkable
    'Welcome to Me' is highly gawkable

    “Why doesn’t it look like ‘Oprah’?” Alice (Kristen Wiig) asks about the production value of her recently launched, guest-free talk show. Responds one of the many employees who can’t believe this series is happening: “Because you ate a cake made out of hamburger and started crying.”

  • Even the outtakes are predictable in 'Hot Pursuit'
    Even the outtakes are predictable in 'Hot Pursuit'

    In February 2013, Melissa McCarthy starred in an unfunny, aggressive road movie (“Identity Thief”). Four months later, she was the wild card to Sandra Bullock’s straight arrow in an incredibly generic buddy cop comedy (“The Heat”). Opening June 5, McCarthy stars in the very funny “Spy” as Susan...

  • Jack Black immediately derails 'The D Train'
    Jack Black immediately derails 'The D Train'

    Hidden in the nagging onslaught of suck that is “The D Train” is a really good scene: Oliver Lawless (James Marsden), the former high school stud who moved from Pittsburgh to L.A. to become an actor, approaches Dermot Mulroney (playing himself), who’s in a bar and being treated like royalty in...

  • Rauner to aldermen: 'For Chicago to get what it wants, Illinois must get what it needs'
    Rauner to aldermen: 'For Chicago to get what it wants, Illinois must get what it needs'

    In an unusual and perhaps unprecedented speech, Gov. Bruce Rauner on Wednesday dropped in at City Hall and offered a time-tested political horse trade: support his controversial pro-business, anti-union agenda, and he'll help Chicago out of its financial free fall.

  • Is Riot Fest dividing the community?

    The questionable return of Riot Fest to Humboldt Park has polarized the community with the local alderman unwaivering in his opposition and the festival organizers launching a full-court press to bring the three-day music festival back.

  • Mayor: Approval of Burge victims fund a step toward 'removing a stain'
    Mayor: Approval of Burge victims fund a step toward 'removing a stain'

    In a dramatic moment Wednesday, the Chicago City Council rose to acknowledge victims of torture at the hands of former police Cmdr. Jon Burge before approving a $5.5 million reparations package that Mayor Rahm Emanuel said shows Chicago is willing to deal with the dark chapter in its history.