Results of state investigation don't tell whole story of Notre Dame videographer's death

When a Notre Dame student videographer reported to work Oct. 27 on a day gusty enough for the National Weather Service to issue a wind advisory, he claimed video coordinator Tim Collins informed him practice would be outdoors "contrary to his judgment.''

Collins' weather concerns also seemed apparent when he kept a female worker off a hydraulic lift at the beginning of practice so as not to scare her and when he ordered two other videographers to go halfway as high as normal.

Players likely weren't in danger in those conditions. The videographers who taped their every move obviously would be.

But when an Indiana Occupational Health and Safety Administration investigator asked Collins directly if he felt the lifts shouldn't be used because of the conditions, he oddly answered, "No.''

Is Collins, a loyal Notre Dame employee for 21 years, covering for somebody? Clearly his actions displayed caution his words contradicted for reasons only he knows. He declined comment through the athletic department.

"I noticed the weather till we went out and felt we were in a safe range to use the lifts,'' Collins said, according to details included in the Indiana OSHA report the Tribune obtained Tuesday.

If you hoped the nearly five-month investigation into Declan Sullivan's death would help determine who at Notre Dame was most responsible for sending the student videographer into a scissors lift on a remarkably windy day, forget it.

Indiana OSHA fined Notre Dame $77,500 for six safety violations related to the incident. The school deserves credit for the way president Rev. John Jenkins took responsibility for Sullivan's death last fall and for announcing last week it was replacing scissors lifts with remote-controlled cameras.

But IOSHA interviews with 12 university employees, including athletic director Jack Swarbrick and football coach Brian Kelly who Notre Dame made unavailable for comment, revealed little more than a giant communication gap under the Golden Dome.

Swarbrick, for example, was asked who specifically approved usage of the scissors lift Sullivan was in 39 feet above ground when it blew over. The question the CEO of any athletic department should have expected in a formal interview with a state regulatory agency stumped the former lawyer.

"I don't (know) a specific person,'' Swarbrick said. "It is done on the administration side of the football program.''

Alas, the man in charge of that football program, Kelly, didn't shed more light on anything — other than he and Swarbrick got their stories straight about the wind that apparently wasn't. It was Swarbrick, you may recall, quoted describing the weather as "unremarkable.''

Kelly's description similarly defied logic considering Indiana OSHA's report cited wind gusts as high as 51 mph.

"It was a beautiful day,'' Kelly told the IOSHA investigator. "We were conducting a normal practice structure when a big gust hit me.''

A normal practice? Was that why the female student videographer was grounded?

Asked if he was in charge of any responsibilities involving the photographers who videotaped Irish football practices, Kelly answered no. Asked if he decides where practices are held, Kelly merely acknowledged he "relies on information from my support staff.''

If Kelly took such a hands-off role on Saturdays, he never would make a decision and Notre Dame would lead the country in delay-of-game penalties.

Besides Swarbrick and Kelly seeming vaguer than one might hope, there was the Dec. 1, 2010, letter from university lawyer Claire Aigotti to an IOSHA investigator requesting video the Notre Dame film crew had taken that day.

Aigotti said the investigator could view the video in her office but she couldn't ship it because it contained, "highly proprietary trade secret information.''

In the midst of trying to get to the bottom of what caused an avoidable fatality, Notre Dame's still worried about football opponents getting an edge?

The closest the investigation came to identifying a flash point in the decision to have practice outdoors that day came during head athletic trainer Jim Russ' interview. Russ recounted a mid-morning conversation he had that fateful day with Kelly staffer Chad Klunder, the director of football operations, after Russ noted wind gusts had registered 27 mph.

"I said, 'I assume we are going outside,' '' Russ told the investigator. "Chad responded, 'Yes, unless the weather dictates we can't.' I said, 'OK, no problem.'''

Ultimately it might be no problem for Russ. But if Notre Dame identifies mid-level scapegoats to spare Kelly and Swarbrick, Klunder and Collins look like prime candidates based on IOSHA's report.

This is a university that once fired George O'Leary for fudging his resume. If Notre Dame's independent investigation due next month doesn't recommend at least somebody losing his job after the loss of a 20-year-old's life, its findings will be dismissed as a sham.

The most honest, damning comments might have come from Sullivan himself. When he found out from assistant video coordinator Reuel Joaquin the team would be practicing outside, Sullivan wasn't happy, according to the report.

"Aw, man,'' Sullivan said. "This sucks.''

Everything about this tragedy does.

Copyright © 2015, RedEye
Related Content
  • Archive of Indiana OSHA investigation

    Archive of Indiana OSHA investigation

    Archive of Indiana OSHA investigation By Stacy St. Clair and Todd Lighty, Tribune reporters At the conclusion of its nearly five-month review, the Indiana Occupational Safety and Health Administration released roughly 500 records it relied on when investigating Declan Sullivan's death at the University...

  • Photos: Notre Dame student killed in accident

    Photos: Notre Dame student killed in accident

    Declan Sullivan, a student at Notre Dame, died on October 27, 2010, after a scissor lift he was standing on fell over while he was shooting football practice.

  • Aldermen looking to stop stores from getting around plastic bag ban

    Aldermen looking to stop stores from getting around plastic bag ban

    Chicago's ban on plastic bags starts to take effect at many big stores Saturday, but an alderman who helped craft the law already is talking about changing it in order to thwart a few large retail chains that he says are trying to skirt the new rules.

  • State police: Man shot while riding in van on Eisenhower

    State police: Man shot while riding in van on Eisenhower

    A man was shot multiple times while traveling in a minivan on the inbound Eisenhower Expressway on Friday morning, authorities said.

  • Lollapalooza liquor gardening: fact or fiction?

    Lollapalooza liquor gardening: fact or fiction?

    It may sound like an urban legend: Music festival-goers bury bottles of booze in Chicago parks, plot a GPS location for the goods and uncover them days later when the festival comes alive.

  • Chicago plans to cut O'Hare noise by rotating runways at night

    Chicago plans to cut O'Hare noise by rotating runways at night

    The Emanuel administration on Friday will propose an experiment at O'Hare International Airport to rotate the runways used late at night, possibly on a weekly basis, to spread out jet noise, the city's aviation chief told the Chicago Tribune.

  • Almost 6 acres of land added near Fullerton Avenue Beach

    Almost 6 acres of land added near Fullerton Avenue Beach

    Along Chicago's lakefront at Fullerton Avenue Beach, cranes rolled along a causeway that only a few months ago was part of the lake itself. Every day this summer, roughly 40 construction workers are filling in Lake Michigan with dredged material and gravel, which will eventually add up to 5.8 acres...

  • Doughnut panic

    Doughnut panic

    I'm not ashamed to admit that for the past several years, I have mapped my walk to work around which doughnut shop I'd like an excuse to stop at on the way. There's nothing like the thought of a crunchy, craggy old fashioned doughnut or the sweet, yeasty chew of a classic glazed doughnut to help...