RedEye

Former MLB VP: 'I doubt the umpires really care about Harrelson'

In a blog Tuesday morning, I speculated about Hawk Harrelson’s rants on umpires.

I pointed out the difference in his outburst when A.J. Pierzynski and Robin Ventura were ejected oSaturday and his silence when Jesse Crain didn’t get a 3-and-2 call in Baltimore on Monday night. The backdrop, of course, is Harrelson’s tirade on plate umpire Mark Wegner in Tampa earlier this season that was followed by phone calls from Commissioner Bud Selig and Sox Chairman Jerry Reinsdorf.

I don’t know if Chairman Reinsdorf had a talk with Harrelson last weekend, but I wrote that if he did, he likely would or should make the point that such outbursts could hurt the team that Harrelson so passionately cares for on the field. Umpires are human, after all. They talk. They know what’s being said, and I can’t imagine they would be too happy about some of the things Harrelson said. Subconsciously, I speculated, it might affect their decisions.

That notion prompted a response from Mike Port, a former general manager who worked for Major League Baseball as the Vice President of Umpiring until March, 2011. Here is his email:

Steve:

I can’t tell you I am the smartest guy in the world, but I can tell you I spent 42 years in Baseball , the last 5 1/2 years of which were spent supervising the Major League umpires.

Are Ken Harrelson’s umpire-related rants hurting the White Sox?

In my opinion -- no.  Maybe the MLB umpires are good at fooling me -- but based upon my experience and acquaintance with them -- I don’t think so.

Several points:

--Just as players try, umpires try.  Players miss ground balls, strike out, throw wild pitches, etc.  Umpires miss on pitches and calls.  But to think umpires “screw up” on purpose is akin to believing that a player would strike out on purpose to aggravate his manager.

--Umpires have great accountability to the Commissioner’s Office.  As you probably know, plate performances are evaluated by the best technology.  And, every call they make is reviewed for accuracy.

--The White Sox.  They have a good club.  Compliments to Kenny Williams and his crew for trying to “rebuild” and compete at the same time.

--Ken Harrelson.  Great personality, but considered an incorrigible, tired act by the umpires.  They consider the source and respect the players’ efforts too much to make mistakes intentionally.

--In Harrelson’s regard, the umpires seem to gravitate to something told to me by Gene Autry (whom I had the privilege of working for with the Angels): “If you see it; why would you step in it?”

A quick review of Harrelson’s umpiring “expertise” would seem to indicate that Harrelson is one of those who thinks that because he once flew on a 747 that he can pilot the damn thing.

I doubt the umpires really care about Harrelson.  One thing I found them to be excellent at is recognizing ignorance.

Best regards.

Mike Port

Copyright © 2015, RedEye
Related Content
  • Do Hawk's umpire rants hurt Sox?

    Do Hawk's umpire rants hurt Sox?

    Maybe it’s me, but listening to the sounds of silence during the sixth inning of the White Sox game in Baltimore on Monday night sounded like Hawk Harrelson was called into the principal's office again.

  • Keeping things 'casual' and the trouble with pity sex

    Keeping things 'casual' and the trouble with pity sex

    Dear Anna: I’ve been seeing this guy very casually for about six months now. It’s going okay, but I’m wondering if it’s possible to ask for more communication and if we might hang out more than once a week, or if this will ruin the whole “casual” vibe. Please advise.—Cool Cat

  • New reality TV show to follow Chicago tattoo artists

    New reality TV show to follow Chicago tattoo artists

    Artists at a Pilsen tattoo shop who claim they "run Chicago" will be the focus of a new VH1 reality TV show, network representatives announced this week. "Black Ink Crew: Chicago," which premieres Oct. 26, profiles the artists at 9Mag tattoo parlor, 2150 S. Canalport Ave. The show "follows a passionate...

  • At least 11 people shot dead, including 11-year-old boy, since late Tuesday in Chicago

    At least 11 people shot dead, including 11-year-old boy, since late Tuesday in Chicago

    At least 11 people have died and 14 others have been wounded in separate shootings in Chicago since late Tuesday, including the accidental shooting of an 11-year-old boy, police said.

  • Emanuel set to call for largest property tax hike in modern Chicago history

    Emanuel set to call for largest property tax hike in modern Chicago history

    Mayor Rahm Emanuel is set to call for the largest property tax increase in modern Chicago history to raise enough money to make a major pension payment for police and firefighters next year, the mayor's City Council floor leader and a City Hall source told the Chicago Tribune late Wednesday.

  • Security ushers Emanuel away as Dyett protesters take to stage at budget hearing

    Security ushers Emanuel away as Dyett protesters take to stage at budget hearing

    Mayor Rahm Emanuel had to be ushered off by his security detail during a public hearing on the city budget Wednesday night after protesters trying to keep a South Side high school open took to the stage.

  • Best new movies

    Best new movies

    Reviews of recent favorites like 'Queen of Earth,' 'We Are Your Friends,' 'Digging for Fire,' 'Straight Outta Compton,' 'The Man From U.N.C.L.E.,' 'The End of the Tour,' 'The Gift, 'Ricki and the Flash,' 'Mission: Impossible--Rogue Nation,' 'Ant-Man,' 'Amy,' 'Magic Mike XXL,' 'The Overnight,' 'Me...

  • Chicago college football bar guide

    Chicago college football bar guide

    Chicago's only big sports conflict for most of the year is Cubs vs. Sox, but when college football season kicks off, North Side or South Side is much less relevant than your alma mater. The Big 10 might dominate here, but the diverse city means you'll find sports bars dedicated to a huge range...

Comments
Loading
87°